In winter weather, drivers need excellent tyres to cope with the harsh conditions.
Winter does exhibit different weather conditions. You will have everything from dry sunny winter conditions, to dark cold windy weather with icy roads. To handle these conditions together with the sub-zero temperatures, you will need tyres that are designed to work under these conditions. Tyres that are not designed for these conditions are extremely dangerous to drive with. They will basically have no grip when you face ice and will perform badly in all conditions when the temperatures are low, as the rubber compound in the tyres will be very hard and brittle at these temperatures. It is associated with great danger to try to drive with tyres that are not suitable for the purpose.
The choice for best winter tyres, should be limited to tyres that have been tested and approved for winter conditions, they have the alpine symbol, which is a mountain with a snowflake inside it. If your tyre doesn’t have this and there is snow outside, you should leave your car and seek other form of transportation, until the weather changes or you have managed to change the tyres.
Tyres that have been tested and approved for winter include some all-weather tyres and then the full range of studded and non-studded winter tyres. The all-weather tyres are perfect if the winters are not so harsh and not so long. When you experience long harsh winters, there is no reason not to change into dedicated winter tyres, to ensure that you will remain safe on the roads while driving. If you want extra grip, then the studded tyres will give you that. If you drive mainly in snowy conditions, then a non-studded tyre should be your choice; they have less rolling resistance, which will save you money due to better fuel efficiency.
Both tyre options if you buy high quality tyres, are nowadays so advanced that they will both provide you with an excellent driving experience during the winter. They will allow you to maneuver on winter surfaces and yield a short braking distance. So both options will for sure get you through the winter safely, but the studded does perform better on icy roads, due to the metal studs. So if you are looking for that extra traction, then that should be your choice. If not then go for non-studded tyres.